Where NotchStar appears with an external display
With an external display, NotchStar stays on the screen that has the notch. On a MacBook with a notch, that is the built in display. The notch does not move to the external monitor, and it does not copy itself onto it.
How the screen is chosen
NotchStar looks for the first screen that reports a notch. If it finds one, it uses that screen. If none of your screens has a notch, it uses the main display that macOS reports, and shows the floating pill there. It checks again whenever the screen setup changes, for example when you plug in or unplug a monitor.
What this means for you
- Laptop with a notch and an external monitor: use the notch on the laptop screen. Move the pointer to the top centre of that screen.
- Laptop with the lid closed and only an external display: there is no notch screen, so NotchStar shows the pill on the main display.
- A desktop Mac with one or two monitors: the pill appears on the main display.
If it is in the wrong place
Unplug and replug the display, or quit and reopen NotchStar from the star in the menu bar. If the notch still does not open, see why the notch does not open.
The Screenshot Tray also hangs under the notch on the same screen. Read about Macs without a notch for the pill.